I like writing down my thoughts after finishing a game. If I don’t, I forget the details surprisingly fast. After a few months, all I can remember is “yeah, that was pretty good” which isn’t very useful.
So I made this template. It forces me to actually think about what I played instead of just moving on to the next thing.
The Template
## Game Review: [Title]
### What's it about?
### Who would like it?
### What is the gameplay like?
### Does one specific element stand out?
### What elements did you like?
### What elements did you dislike?
### How does it compare to similar games?
### Final thoughtsWhat each section is for
What’s it about?
Just the basics. What’s the setting, what’s the story setup. I keep it vague to avoid spoilers. Mostly this is so I can remember “oh right, that was the one with the time loop” or whatever.
Who would like it?
This one’s actually the most useful part. “It’s good” doesn’t tell anyone anything. But “if you liked Hollow Knight you’ll probably like this” or “great if you want something relaxing after work” gives people something to work with.
What is the gameplay like?
How does it feel to actually play? Is it twitchy? Slow and methodical? Did I play it in long sessions or short bursts? How long did it take to finish?
Does one specific element stand out?
Some games have that one thing you remember forever. The soundtrack, a plot twist, a boss fight, the art style. If something stuck with me, I write it down here.
What elements did you like?
What worked. I try to be specific instead of generic stuff like “good graphics.”
What elements did you dislike?
What didn’t work. Even games I love have annoying parts. Being honest here helps me remember the full picture and helps anyone reading know what they’re getting into.
How does it compare to similar games?
A game can be mediocre compared to the best in its genre but still worth playing. Or it might be technically impressive but worse than a ten year old game in the same genre. Comparisons give context.
Final thoughts
Quick wrap-up. Would I recommend it? To who?
Why bother?
Mostly for myself. It’s nice to look back at what I played and actually remember my opinions. The template keeps me from rambling and makes sure I don’t skip anything important.